Blake Robertson's Dismissed Assault Case Reportedly Surfaces as 'The Ultimatum' Returns
The reality star's legal past is officially cleared, but the personal reckoning his co-star wants is still playing out off-screen.
Season 4 of Netflix's "The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On" hit the streaming platform last week, bringing renewed attention to star Blake Robertson's off-screen legal troubles.
According to TMZ, Robertson was arrested in October 2025 at a business in Nacogdoches, Texas, after he allegedly assaulted his girlfriend and co-star, Hayley Hendrich. The incident occurred after filming for the dating show had wrapped.
Hendrich told TMZ she declined to press charges. She also revealed they had private conversations about the incident but would like Robertson to publicly take accountability. Page Six reached out to Hendrich for comment but did not immediately hear back.
Robertson’s attorney, Sean Hightower, offered a different perspective to the outlet. "Blake’s case was rightfully dismissed by the prosecutor almost immediately, and all records were expunged."
On the show, Robertson gave Hendrich an ultimatum. Hendrich was reportedly reluctant, wanting Robertson to "open up more emotionally," per Netflix.
Sources
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Blake Robertson known for?
He is a star on Season 4 of Netflix's reality dating show 'The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On.'
When was Blake Robertson arrested?
He was arrested in October 2025.
Where did the arrest take place?
He was taken into custody at a business in Nacogdoches, Texas.
What has his attorney said about the case?
His attorney, Sean Hightower, told TMZ the case was 'rightfully dismissed by the prosecutor almost immediately, and all records were expunged.'
More from The Screen Report
Nick and Vanessa Lachey Boot a Couple From 'The Ultimatum' After a Secret Note Is Intercepted
The hosts prove that on their show, covert communication is the one ultimatum they won't tolerate, leading to an unprecedented dismissal.
Blake Lively Reportedly Gets a Second Chance Ahead of Swift-Kelce Wedding
An olive branch in the form of an invitation may have repaired a fractured friendship. Not everyone on the guest list was so eager to attend.
Holly Willoughby Launches Lifestyle Series 'Holly Willoughby Together' on YouTube
The first episode of the new lifestyle show, featuring guests like Stanley Tucci and Katherine Ryan, will debut on July 28.
Fessler Reveals She's Received No Apology from Miller Over West Wilson Claims
One Bravo star has made amends, but the other remains silent, leaving a public accusation hanging in the 'Summer House' air.