Lewis Pullman Joins Julia Garner in Apple TV+ True Crime Series 'Guilty Creatures'
The Emmy-nominated actor will play a lead role opposite Garner in the drama based on a real Florida murder case.

- Show
- Guilty Creatures
- Network
- Apple TV+
- Status
- ordered
- Lewis Pullman as Lead Role
“torrid romance and subsequent act of murder between two young, adulterous but God-fearing lovers, unraveling their complex lives and the emotional toll of living as killers for 18 years”
Lewis Pullman has been cast in a lead role opposite Julia Garner in Apple TV+'s forthcoming true crime drama series "Guilty Creatures," according to The Hollywood Reporter. The Emmy-nominated actor joins the project based on Mikita Brottman's book "Guilty Creatures: Sex, God, and Murder in Tallahassee, Florida."
What is 'Guilty Creatures' about?
The series will delve into the "torrid romance and subsequent act of murder between two young, adulterous but God-fearing lovers, unraveling their complex lives and the emotional toll of living as killers for 18 years," per its official logline. Brottman's book chronicles the events following the December 2000 disappearance of Mike Williams in the Florida panhandle. No body was found, but five years later, his long-time friend divorced his wife and married Williams' wife, with the truth emerging 12 years after that.
Who is making the series?
Tomorrow Studios, an ITV Studios partner, is producing the series. The project was developed via first-look deals with Julia Garner's Alma Margo and director/executive producer Craig Gillespie's Fortunate Jack Productions. Stuart Zicherman serves as showrunner and executive producer alongside writer Sarah DeLappe, Garner, Tomorrow Studios' Marty Adelstein, Becky Clements and Alissa Bachner, Gillespie and Annie Marter for Fortunate Jack, and author Mikita Brottman.
Pullman's recent credits include the Netflix film "Remarkably Bright Creatures" and an Emmy-nominated role in Apple's "Lessons in Chemistry." He will next appear as Bob Reynolds/Sentry in "Avengers: Doomsday."
Frequently Asked Questions
What real-life case is 'Guilty Creatures' based on?
The series is based on the disappearance of Mike Williams in the Florida panhandle in December 2000. The case involved complex relationships, as his friend later married Williams' wife, with the full truth of the murder not coming to light for many years.
Who else is involved in the production?
Director Craig Gillespie is attached as an executive producer. The showrunner is Stuart Zicherman, and the book is being adapted for television by writer Sarah DeLappe. Production companies involved include Tomorrow Studios, Alma Margo, and Fortunate Jack Productions.
More from The Screen Report

Steven Moffat to Headline Barcelona's Serielizados Festival in October
The 'Sherlock' creator and 'Doctor Who' showrunner will be joined by producer Sue Vertue as the event's international guest.

Ed Harris Felt 'Misled' About His Role on 'Dutton Ranch'
The actor told Variety he was frustrated by his character's limited screen time in the first season of the 'Yellowstone' spinoff.

Maitreyi Ramakrishnan Cast as Elle Woods' Nemesis in Elle Season 2
The Never Have I Ever alum will play Sam, a character she says is 'not something I've done before' in the Legally Blonde prequel.

Cooper Flagg & Family to Battle Barstool on Celebrity Family Feud
The NBA Rookie of the Year will compete alongside his twin brother, Ace, and other family members on ABC's game show.